October 18th, 2002

LGBT

Audre Lourde and sacred cows

Riki Wilchins and Patricia Ireland came to Rochester last night to give a lecture at RIT as part of their women's week. Riki did her usual riff on gender and postmodernism and how Labels Are Bad, and banged the drum to try to recruit people for GenderPAC. (bcholmes, you'll be interested to know that she also brought up the inevitable anecdote about being asked which way she had transitioned....) Patricia followed up by quoting Audre Lourde about how "the master's tools can never dismantle the master's house."

Everywhere I go in my activism, someone invariably trots out that quote, and I've never understood why it is quoted and accepted so uncritically. Why can't the master's tools dismantle the house? Couldn't they possibly be the most effective ones? And can't the master's gun shoot the master dead?

No one has ever been able to satisfactorily explain the passage to me, even people who use it to cut off debate. I asked Patricia about it afterwards, and she admitted that it's a "challenging" passage... and that in her current work, she found tools such as voting and legal action to be quite effective.

So... what am I missing here? And why has this become an unquestioned article of faith among progressive activists?
  • Current Music
    Amber Benson -- Under Your Spell
  • Tags
    ,